I found this article interesting and a bit heart-breaking,
but did not gain much new information.
Many of the structural assets and roadblocks embedded in a school system
were predictable.
I do, however like the idea of interviewing students and
putting ELLs in the position of the “expert.” I would like to incorporate this
into my study design by putting student opinion and sense of value at the
forefront of the design.
Also, I feel like passing on these “predictable” bits of
information and advice for classroom teachers would be repetitive, if not even
insulting to teachers. I definitely
struggle with providing professional advice for my colleagues, whom I deeply
respect, but at times fall short when instructing our ELLs. We are a very small staff, and my “Minnesota
Nice” demeanor makes it difficult for me to deliver ideas/suggestions without
feeling that I am insulting a person.
For example, when I read about the student who felt completely isolated
when asked to choose a partner, I wanted to email all staff with a reminder on this topic. These are touchy issues, but my staff does
need these reminders. Striking the
balance in delivering the information is essential.
I really hear what you are saying. AND, I agree! The secret is striking the balance. While you may not have received any "new information from this article, sometimes it is nice to be reminded of what we already know and have not remembered...perhaps your staff would feel the same way.
ReplyDelete